Alina
Bihar Vendor Killed Over Dispute
Bihar’s Kako Village Shocked After Elderly Vendor Killed Over Minor Dispute
A tragic incident has shaken Bihar’s Jehanabad district where a 70-year-old vegetable vendor, Mohammed Mohsin, was brutally beaten to death in front of his minor grandson. The killing, reportedly over a small toll fee dispute of just a few rupees, has sparked outrage across the state and renewed debate over public safety, political patronage, and the breakdown of social order.
The Incident in Brief
According to police in Kako village, Jehanabad district, the shocking event occurred on Wednesday, September 18. Mohammed Mohsin, a local vendor known for selling fruits and vegetables, had arrived at the bustling market area accompanied by his grandson. Witnesses recount that an altercation erupted between Mohsin and a local youth, Vicky Patel, over the payment of a small toll fee.
How the Dispute Began
Mohsin, who regularly paid the small toll charged to vendors in the market, reportedly had only ₹10 available at the time, while Patel demanded ₹15. Mohsin is said to have assured Patel he would pay the remaining amount later in the day. However, Patel insisted on full payment immediately, leading to an argument.
Several bystanders later told local media that Mohsin remained calm and explained his situation, emphasizing that he had never defaulted on toll payments before. Despite this, Patel reportedly became agitated and aggressive.
The Fatal Attack
Eyewitnesses say that during the heated exchange, Patel picked up a nearby dumbbell – apparently used as a weight in one of the shops – and struck Mohsin repeatedly on the stomach and head. The impact was so severe that the elderly man collapsed instantly, bleeding heavily. His young grandson, traumatized and helpless, witnessed the entire assault.
Reports indicate Mohsin died on the spot before any medical aid could be administered. Some local sources claim his body remained in the market area for several hours before being removed, sparking further anger about the community’s response and the apparent lack of immediate intervention.
Police Action and Legal Proceedings
Kako police have registered a case under Section 103 (murder) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) against Vicky Patel. Despite efforts to track him down, the accused remains at large. Police officials have assured the public that raids are underway to arrest Patel and that no one will be spared from prosecution.
A senior police officer told local media that they are also examining CCTV footage from the market area to piece together the sequence of events and identify any possible accomplices or witnesses.
Political Controversy Surrounding the Case
The case has taken a political turn after photos of Vicky Patel with Bihar’s Deputy Chief Ministers Samrat Chaudhary and Vijay Kumar Sinha, as well as other BJP leaders, surfaced on social media. Critics have alleged that Patel may have enjoyed political patronage or impunity.
Congress leader and Rajya Sabha MP Imran Pratapgarhi condemned the incident, calling it evidence of “Jungle Raj” in Bihar. In a widely shared post on X (formerly Twitter), he wrote:
“This is real Jungle Raj of Bihar. A vegetable vendor was murdered over five rupees. BJP’s allies are not able to govern Bihar.”
This statement has intensified the debate about law and order in the state, with opposition parties accusing the ruling coalition of failing to ensure public safety.
Life and Struggles of Mohammed Mohsin
Neighbors describe Mohammed Mohsin as a hardworking man who had been selling fruits and vegetables for decades to support his family. Widely respected in his community, Mohsin was known for his honesty and gentle demeanor. The day of the incident, he had taken his grandson to the market as part of his routine.
Family members say Mohsin was the sole breadwinner for his household. His sudden, violent death has left them devastated, both emotionally and financially. Community leaders have demanded immediate compensation and government assistance for his surviving family.
Impact on the Grandson and Witnesses
The most heart-wrenching element of the case is the presence of Mohsin’s minor grandson at the crime scene. Psychologists say witnessing such a violent act can have severe long-term trauma effects on children, including anxiety, nightmares, and distrust of public spaces. Social workers in the region have called for immediate counseling for the boy.
Witnesses too are grappling with shock, with some admitting guilt for not intervening. In India, fear of reprisals or legal entanglement often discourages bystanders from intervening in violent disputes.
Community Reactions
Residents of Kako and neighboring areas have expressed outrage over both the brutality of the incident and the community’s inaction. Several local organizations held candlelight vigils demanding swift justice and stronger policing. Others criticized the apparent desensitization of society, as reports suggested Mohsin’s body lay in public view for hours without intervention.
The Broader Issue of Market Tolls
Local vendors say disputes over small tolls are common but rarely escalate to violence. Informal toll collection in rural markets is a long-standing practice, often handled by local youth or municipal contractors. However, lack of regulation and transparency can breed conflict and corruption.
Some community leaders are now calling for the formalization of toll systems and oversight by local governing bodies to prevent harassment and extortion of small vendors.
Bihar’s Law and Order Question
The killing of Mohammed Mohsin raises uncomfortable questions about Bihar’s law and order situation. Despite government claims of modernization and improved policing, high-profile crimes continue to grab headlines. Critics point to the persistence of “goonda raj” and argue that entrenched political patronage shields perpetrators from accountability.
The state government, however, maintains that swift action is being taken in all such cases and that no one, regardless of connections, will be above the law.
Social Media and the Spread of the Story
The case gained nationwide attention after graphic details and images circulated on social media. Hashtags like #JusticeForMohsin and #BiharJungleRaj trended for hours. Activists and journalists highlighted the incident as a reflection of deep-rooted social and administrative issues, including the vulnerability of minority communities, the plight of informal workers, and public apathy.
Psychological Impact on the Community
Sociologists note that repeated exposure to violence in public spaces erodes communal trust and civic life. When people see bodies lying unattended or assaults going unchallenged, it normalizes a climate of fear and indifference. This eroded civic engagement can have long-term consequences for democracy and social cohesion.
Legal and Administrative Follow-Up
Legal experts suggest the state government can expedite the trial under fast-track courts. Compensation under victim relief funds is also possible for the family. Civil society groups are pressing for a fair and impartial investigation, free from political influence.
Some activists have also demanded witness protection for those willing to testify, as fear of retaliation often leads to weak cases in court.
Lessons and Preventive Measures
Incidents like this underline the urgent need for:
-
Regulated Market Practices: Transparent toll collection to prevent extortion.
-
Increased Policing: Visible police presence in crowded markets during peak hours.
-
Community Vigilance: Encouraging bystanders to report or intervene safely using helplines.
-
Legal Literacy Campaigns: Educating small vendors about their rights and avenues for grievance redressal.
Comparisons With Similar Incidents
Unfortunately, Bihar has seen multiple incidents of mob violence or disputes escalating to fatalities. In 2023, a similar toll-related dispute in a different district resulted in serious injuries. This trend points to systemic governance issues rather than isolated cases.
Call for Justice from Civil Society
Human rights groups have called on the Bihar State Human Rights Commission to take suo motu cognizance of the case. They argue that beyond arresting the accused, the state must also examine the institutional failures that allowed such a crime to occur openly and go unchecked for hours.
Looking Forward
As of now, the prime accused Vicky Patel remains on the run, and the family of Mohammed Mohsin awaits justice. Police insist they are close to apprehending Patel and will prosecute him to the fullest extent of the law.
For Bihar’s government, the incident represents both a challenge and an opportunity: to demonstrate its commitment to justice, public safety, and rule of law. For civil society, it’s a moment to reflect on how public indifference can sometimes embolden perpetrators of violence.
Conclusion
The killing of 70-year-old Mohammed Mohsin over a trivial dispute has sparked shock, anger, and introspection across Bihar and beyond. What should have been an ordinary day at the market became a fatal encounter, leaving a family shattered and a community questioning its own conscience.
As Bihar grapples with political and social fallout, the incident underscores the pressing need for transparent market regulations, stronger law enforcement, and a culture of civic responsibility. Until then, small vendors like Mohammed Mohsin will continue to face vulnerabilities that extend far beyond financial hardship.
Disclaimer:
This article is based on publicly available information, police statements, and media reports. Readers are advised to follow updates from credible and verified news sources for the latest developments.
